×
Never miss a recipe!
And, also get our news and updates
delivered to your inbox!
Join us now
Skip to content
Click to Shop Our Holiday Gift Catalog!
Visit
visit
Hours & Directions
Events at The Old Mill
eat
The Old Mill Restaurant
The Old Mill Pottery House Cafe
The Old Mill Creamery
The Old Mill Candy Kitchen
shop
The Old Mill and General Store
The Old Mill Farmhouse Kitchen
Pigeon River Pottery
Sassafras
sip
Old Forge Distillery
Shop Online
Best Sellers
Collections
From Our Restaurants
Our Stone-Ground Grains
Flavors of Fall
Holiday Gifts
Brands
Pigeon River Pottery
Old Forge Distillery
Gift Cards
Food
Grains
Breakfast
Jams & Jellies
From Our Bakery
Baking Mixes & Batters
Breadings
Soups & Beans
Snacks
Candy
Honey & Sorghum
Syrups & Toppings
Sauces & Salsas
Salts, Peppers & Spices
Pickles & Relishes
Dressings, Oils & Vinegars
Dips
Beverages
Home + Lifestyle
Pigeon River Pottery
Kitchen
Pets
Apothecary
Garden, Outdoor & Patio
Handcrafted
Books & Paper
Handmade/Made in USA
Gifts
Our History
Recipes
Blog
Contact Us
Visit
visit
Hours & Directions
Events at The Old Mill
eat
The Old Mill Restaurant
The Old Mill Pottery House Cafe
The Old Mill Creamery
The Old Mill Candy Kitchen
shop
The Old Mill and General Store
The Old Mill Farmhouse Kitchen
Pigeon River Pottery
Sassafras
sip
Old Forge Distillery
Shop Online
collections
From Our Restaurants
Our Stone-Ground Grains
Flavors of Fall
Holiday Gifts
brands
Pigeon River Pottery
Old Forge Distillery
gift-cards
food
Grains
Breakfast
Jams & Jellies
From Our Bakery
Baking Mixes & Batters
Breadings
Soups & Beans
Snacks
Candy
Honey & Sorghum
Syrups & Toppings
Sauces & Salsas
Salts, Peppers & Spices
Pickles & Relishes
Dressings, Oils & Vinegars
Dips
Beverages
home-lifestyle
Pigeon River Pottery
Kitchen
Pets
Apothecary
Garden, Outdoor & Patio
Handcrafted
Books & Paper
Handmade/Made in USA
Gifts
Our History
Recipes
Blog
Contact Us
Home
›
Gifts Under 50 Dollars
Collections
View All
From Our Restaurants
Our Stone-Ground Grains
Flavors of Fall
Holiday Gifts
View All
Gifts Under $30
Gifts Under $50
Gifts Under $100
Gift Cards
View All
Brands
View All
Pigeon River Pottery
Old Forge Distillery
Food
View All
Grains
View All
Grits & Cornmeal
Flour & Oats
Rice & Grains
Breakfast
Jams & Jellies
View All
Jams
Preserves
Jellies
Fruit Butters
Spreads
From Our Bakery
View All
Cakes, Pastries & Pies
Cookies & Brownies
Breads
Baking Mixes & Batters
Breading
Soups & Beans
View All
Signature Soup Mix
Soup Starters
Beans
Snacks
Candy
View All
Brittles & Toffee
Taffy & Caramels
Stick Candy
Rock Candy
Fruit Jellies
Honey & Sorghum
Syrups & Toppings
View All
Premium
Classic
Sugar-Free
Sauces & Salsas
View All
BBQ Sauce
Marinades
Salsas
Salts, Peppers & Spices
View All
Salts & Peppers
Seasonings
Grilling Rubs
Pickles & Relishes
View All
Pickles
Relishes
Chow-Chow
Pickled Vegetables
Dressings, Oils & Vinegars
Dips
Beverages
View All
Ciders
Coffee & Tea
Home + Lifestyle
View All
Kitchen
View All
Bakeware & Cookware
Cast Iron
Kitchen Decor
Pets
Apothecary
View All
Lotions
Bath
Balms
Scrubs
Soaps
Garden, Outdoor & Patio
Handcrafted
View All
Bowls & Serving
Vases & Crocks
Mugs
Bakeware
Pitchers
Drinkware
Books & Paper
Handmade/Made in USA
Gifts
Filter
Shop
Gifts Under 50 Dollars
Bacon Cooker
$49.99
Chocolate Pecan Pie
$34.99
Batter Bowl
$39.99
Fried Chicken Like Mamas Gift Set
$39.99
Biscuit Lovers` Gift Set
$39.99
Toffee Gift Tin
$39.99
Best Sellers Trio
$39.99
Relish Time With Friends
$39.99
Cranberry Orange Cornmeal Cake
$34.99
Five-Flavor Pound Cake
$34.99
Mini Honey Butter Sampler
$32.99
Winter Soup Gift Set
$34.99
1
2
Next »
