Based on 20 reviews
Great pie family really enjoyed it
Is it possible to give it more stars???? The Pecan Pie is excellent, but the Chocolate Pecan Pie is Super Duper Excellent !!!!!!! Soon I'll be getting more !!!
Chocolate Pecan Pie
I am not a fan of just a pecan pie but one with chocolate I could literally eat every single day. This is the first time I ordered a pie from The Old Mill and it will definitely not be my last time. Absolutely delicious and delivery was quick!!!
One of the chocolate pecan pies was overbaked and one was underbaked. They were edible but not nearly as good as usual so might not order again.