The Old Mill Shop Online

Candy Tins Just Dropped

Sweet Sampler Happy Holidays

Sweet Sampler Happy Holidays

$49.99

Sweet Sampler Merry Christmas

Sweet Sampler Merry Christmas

$49.99

Peppermint Bark Tin

Peppermint Bark Tin

$29.99

Assorted Chocolate Fudge Tin

Assorted Chocolate Fudge Tin

$34.99

Assorted Peanut Butter Fudge Tin

Assorted Peanut Butter Fudge Tin

$34.99

Divinity Tin

$22.99

Chocolate Covered Peanuts Tin

Chocolate Covered Peanuts Tin

$32.99

Assorted Chocolate-Dipped Pretzel Tin

Assorted Chocolate-Dipped Pretzel Tin

$32.99

View all products

Under $50

Gifts for the host

Thank You Gifts

get well & sympathy gifts

Food Gifts

corporate gifts

Shop By Category

From our Restaurants

Old Mill Gift Cards

Shop Gift Cards

Baking Mixes