Taffy Gift Box

16 reviews
$14.99

Our Taffy Gift Box includes a crowd-pleasing selection of our most popular Salt Water Taffy flavors in a beautiful package. It’s as close as anyone will ever come to putting sunshine in a box! Made on our century-old taffy pulling and wrapping machines, sweet and flavorful taffy comes assorted in a souvenir gift box. 1 lb.

This candy was made to be stored at room temperature. During the shipping and delivery, it can get warm and become soft and sticky, or it can get cold and become firm and harder, depending on the time of year. If you let it come back to room temperature before treating yourself, you will find it just as fresh and enjoyable as if you just picked it up in our shop.

Customer Reviews

Based on 16 reviews
69%
(11)
13%
(2)
6%
(1)
0%
(0)
13%
(2)
B
Barbara Hanel
Best Taffy!

We purchased a pound and a half of Taffy in the store in July and we loved it so much that I ordered 4 boxes after we got home. Unfortunately the first shipment was lost during shipping, however I contacted customer service and they sent a new shipment right away. My only issue is that the first box we opened did not have much flavor variation and was mostly the chocolate flavor taffy which is not a favorite. The Tutti fruity and Huckleberry flavors are just delicious!

L
Laurie Holliday
Not good anymore.

We've bought lots of taffy from the Old Mill candy shop for years. Online, and in their shop in Pigeon Forge. I don't know what's happened, but it doesn't taste anything like it used to. It used to be our favorite taffy. It was so good. Now it tastes terrible. I don't know if they've changed owners or what. We'll never buy from them again.

P
Paula Namie

Taffy Gift Box

J
Jeff Wooley
DISAPPOINTED

I ordered two boxes and asked for chocalate, strawberry and banana flavored .only. After they shipped my ordered they contacted me by email that I would have to call and ask for those flavors only. Why did they mail and then notified me. The boxes were barely over half full and not flavors i like. I buy several pounds a year in person and was very disa;pointed

J
Jenny Vincent

Taffy Gift Box

You may also like

Recently viewed