Peanut Butter Fudge

11 reviews

Peanut butter holds a special place in America’s heart—and its stomach! Made with real peanut butter, our rich, dense, creamy Peanut Butter Fudge will have your inner child jumping for joy. What could possibly be sweeter? 

Sold by the pound.

Customer Reviews

Based on 11 reviews
Laura C Zander Racic

Disappointed. Expected more peanut butter flavor.

Robert J Shirley
Best Peanut Butter Fudge

I love peanut butter fudge. I get it every chance I get. When we visited Gatlinburg in May, one of our 1st stops was the Old Mill. I bought peanut butter fudge for me and my adult daughter who is also in love with it. My portion didn’t last the 5 days we were staying there. We had to stop back and buy more. It was fabulous. It is by far the best peanut butter fudge I have ever had. My daughter agreed. Now that I know I can get it online, I may become a regular instead of just a vacation purchaser. Thank you Old Mill. You are the best.

Debi Wills
Best fudge ever!

I visited this candy shop when my family vacationed In Gatlinburg over Christmas. I had the chocolate as well as the peanut butter fudge while there. We returned to our home in Orlando, Florida after New Years Day but by February I was craving the peanut butter fudge so much I just had to find a way to get some. There literally is no better anywhere and trust me I have tasted 100’s of different types in my travels. Suffice to say I was so happy to be able to order this delicious fudge and have it shipped to Florida. They have made a loyal customer in me and I plan to order quite frequently. Keep up the outstanding work!

loretta galloway
Simply the BEST!

I purchased several kinds of fudge yesterday while in the store - it was all simply delicious! However, the peanut butter was above and beyond the BEST! I've bought it many times before while living in the area, but had forgotten how smooth and delicious it is. I'll be back for more soon or will be shopping online!!!!!

Peanut Butter Fudge

It is the best peanut butter fudge my husband and I have ever tasted. My husband says it tastes just like the peanut butter fudge his dad made years ago. It brings back many good memories for him.

You may also like

Recently viewed