Old Mill Restaurant Pecan Pie Gift

Old Mill Restaurant Pecan Pie Gift

$29.99

Folks will drive for miles to get a slice of The Old Mill Restaurant’s legendary Pecan Pie. It’s that good! We’ve been baking and serving our authentic version of this Southern treasure every day for more than 25 years. From the crunchy pecans to the perfect crust, every piece is a slice of holiday heaven.

9” Serves 6-8.

Orders that have perishable items like breads, cakes, or pies will be shipped Monday through Wednesday of every week to ensure a two-day delivery and ultimate freshness. Additional shipping charges may apply to the west coast states. Call 877-653-6455 for details.

 Item # C19128

Customer Reviews

Based on 48 reviews
94%
(45)
2%
(1)
2%
(1)
2%
(1)
0%
(0)
a
a.t.
Pecan pie delivery

Best pecan pie ever I ordered it online and had it in 2 days the pies were perfect.

L
L.S.
over cooked pecan pie

I have made pecan pie for 61 years of marriage. This pecan pie was over cooked and as a result the crust was tough and difficult to cut. The inside of the pie was , therefore also overcooked and the flavor wasn't as good. We missed the vanilla flavor completely. Did you use your Mexican vanilla? I think it would be good if you didn't over cook it. Use a table knife and test 1/2 between the center and the edge of the pie. I would not order it again.

J
J.P.

Delicious as always!

K
K.
Deliciousness

We first had a taste of this pie when we ate dinner at the restaurant. We couldn’t resist ordering it online for Valentines Day. We live in Hawaii and the timing of delivery was perfect. Definitely will order again! Thank You!

M
M.T.
Disappointed

This pie was OK, no better tasting than a store bought pecan pie and not worth the price Old Mill is charging..

Customer Reviews

Based on 48 reviews
94%
(45)
2%
(1)
2%
(1)
2%
(1)
0%
(0)
a
a.t.
Pecan pie delivery

Best pecan pie ever I ordered it online and had it in 2 days the pies were perfect.

L
L.S.
over cooked pecan pie

I have made pecan pie for 61 years of marriage. This pecan pie was over cooked and as a result the crust was tough and difficult to cut. The inside of the pie was , therefore also overcooked and the flavor wasn't as good. We missed the vanilla flavor completely. Did you use your Mexican vanilla? I think it would be good if you didn't over cook it. Use a table knife and test 1/2 between the center and the edge of the pie. I would not order it again.

J
J.P.

Delicious as always!

K
K.
Deliciousness

We first had a taste of this pie when we ate dinner at the restaurant. We couldn’t resist ordering it online for Valentines Day. We live in Hawaii and the timing of delivery was perfect. Definitely will order again! Thank You!

M
M.T.
Disappointed

This pie was OK, no better tasting than a store bought pecan pie and not worth the price Old Mill is charging..