The Old Mill Restaurant Pecan Pie

80 reviews

Folks will drive for miles to get a slice of The Old Mill Restaurant’s legendary Pecan Pie. It’s that good! We’ve been baking and serving our authentic version of this Southern treasure every day for more than 25 years. From the crunchy pecans to the perfect crust, every piece is a slice of holiday heaven.

9” Serves 6-8.

Orders that have perishable items like breads, cakes, or pies will be shipped Monday through Wednesday of every week to ensure a two-day delivery and ultimate freshness. Additional shipping charges may apply to the west coast states. Call 877-653-6455 for details.

Customer Reviews

Based on 80 reviews
Kelly Cox

This is the best pecan pie we have ever eaten. We spend $70 to have 5 shipped to Idaho. We freeze them and when we run out we order again.

Nick Skargee


Paul Nelson
Good pecan pie

The pies we ordered arrived in good shape and in a timely manner. WE served them for desert at our family Christmas dinner and everyoe thought they were great. We of course were glad to have pie leftover for just my wife and myself and again they were really enjoyed in some quiter moments after Christmas Day. it was sad to see the last piece gone but we know where some more are when the occasion arises.
Paul Nelson

Paul Havens
Peacan pies

This was the best peacan pie ever , better then Cracker Barrel’s

Wanda Joyce Avans
Pecan pie

I love the crunchy and taste of the pie. I need more :)

You may also like

Recently viewed